Examine tools for assessing package security and license compliance

13 minutes

Numerous Software Composition Analysis tools are available, each with different strengths, capabilities, and integration approaches. Selecting the appropriate tool requires understanding your organization's specific requirements, development workflows, technology stack, and budget. This unit examines leading SCA tools and provides guidance for evaluating and selecting the right solution.

Leading SCA tools

GitHub Dependabot

GitHub Dependabot is GitHub's integrated dependency management tool providing automated vulnerability alerts and dependency updates.

Key capabilities:

Vulnerability alerts: Automatic alerts for vulnerable dependencies based on GitHub Advisory Database.
Automated updates: Creates pull requests automatically to fix vulnerabilities and update dependencies.
Dependency graph: Visualizes dependency relationships in GitHub repository interface.
Security updates: Prioritizes pull requests that fix security vulnerabilities.
Version updates: Keeps dependencies up to date according to configurable schedules.
Compatibility scores: Calculates likelihood that updates will break existing functionality.

Integration capabilities:

Native GitHub integration: Deeply integrated into GitHub workflows with no additional setup.
Pull request workflow: Uses standard GitHub pull request review and approval processes.
CI/CD triggering: Pull requests automatically trigger existing CI/CD checks.
Security tab: Centralized security dashboard showing all vulnerability alerts.
API access: GitHub API provides programmatic access to Dependabot alerts and updates.

Pricing model:

Free for public repositories: Completely free for public open-source projects.
Included with GitHub: Included with all GitHub pricing tiers for private repositories.
No additional cost: No per-developer or per-project fees.

Limitations:

GitHub only: Requires using GitHub for source control; not available for other platforms.
Limited ecosystem support: Supports common ecosystems but not as comprehensive as commercial tools.
Basic reporting: Limited reporting and analytics compared to commercial solutions.
No binary scanning: Only analyzes manifest files; doesn't scan compiled binaries or containers.
Limited license compliance: Displays license information but lacks advanced compliance features.

Best suited for:

GitHub users: Teams already using GitHub for source control.
Open-source projects: Public repositories benefiting from free security scanning.
Simple use cases: Projects with straightforward dependency management needs.

Mend (formerly WhiteSource)

Mend is a comprehensive commercial SCA platform emphasizing automated remediation and developer-friendly workflows.

Key capabilities:

Automated remediation: Automatically generates pull requests to fix vulnerable dependencies.
Effective usage analysis: Identifies whether vulnerable code paths are actually executed by your application to reduce false positives.
License compliance: Comprehensive license detection and policy enforcement across 200+ license types.
Multi-language support: Supports over 200 programming languages and package managers.
Container scanning: Scans container images for vulnerabilities in base images and application dependencies.
SBOM generation: Creates CycloneDX and SPDX-format software bill of materials.

Integration capabilities:

IDE plugins: Real-time scanning in Visual Studio Code, IntelliJ IDEA, Eclipse, and Visual Studio.
CI/CD integration: Native plugins for Azure Pipelines, GitHub Actions, Jenkins, GitLab CI, CircleCI, and Travis CI.
Repository integration: Direct integration with GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, and Azure Repos.
Package repository scanning: Connects to Azure Artifacts, Artifactory, Nexus for repository-level scanning.
Issue tracking: Integration with Jira, ServiceNow, and Azure Boards for vulnerability tracking.

Pricing model:

Commercial product: Subscription-based pricing per developer or per project.
Free tier: Mend Bolt offers limited free functionality for open-source projects.
Enterprise licensing: Volume discounts and custom enterprise agreements available.

Best suited for:

Enterprise organizations: Large teams needing comprehensive SCA with advanced features.
Regulated industries: Organizations requiring detailed compliance reporting and audit trails.
Multi-language environments: Teams working across diverse technology stacks.

Snyk

Snyk is a developer-focused security platform offering SCA alongside container security, infrastructure as code scanning, and application security testing.

Key capabilities:

Developer experience: Emphasizes developer-friendly workflows and clear remediation guidance.
Comprehensive vulnerability database: Curated vulnerability database with detailed remediation advice.
Fix pull requests: Automatically creates pull requests with dependency upgrades fixing vulnerabilities.
Reachability analysis: Determines whether vulnerable functions are actually called by your code.
License compliance: License detection and policy enforcement with customizable policies.
Container security: Scans container images and provides base image recommendations.
Infrastructure as Code: Scans Terraform, CloudFormation, Kubernetes YAML, and ARM templates.

Integration capabilities:

Git integration: Deep integration with GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, and Azure Repos.
CI/CD plugins: Plugins for Azure Pipelines, GitHub Actions, Jenkins, CircleCI, GitLab CI.
IDE extensions: Plugins for VS Code, IntelliJ IDEA, Visual Studio, Eclipse.
Container registries: Integrates with Docker Hub, Azure Container Registry, Amazon ECR, Google Container Registry.
Kubernetes monitoring: Monitors deployed Kubernetes workloads for vulnerabilities.

Pricing model:

Free tier: Limited free tier for individual developers and small open-source projects.
Team plan: Per-developer pricing for small to medium teams.
Business and Enterprise: Advanced features, priority support, and dedicated success managers.

Best suited for:

Developer-centric teams: Teams prioritizing developer experience and workflow integration.
Cloud-native applications: Organizations heavily using containers and Kubernetes.
Comprehensive security: Teams wanting unified platform for multiple security testing types.

OWASP Dependency-Check

OWASP Dependency-Check is a free, open-source SCA tool maintained by the OWASP (Open Web Application Security Project) community.

Key capabilities:

Vulnerability detection: Identifies dependencies with known vulnerabilities using the National Vulnerability Database (NVD).
Multi-language support: Supports Java, .NET, JavaScript, Ruby, Python, and more.
CVE identification: Maps dependencies to CVE identifiers with CVSS scores.
False positive suppression: XML-based suppression file for managing false positives.
Flexible reporting: Generates reports in HTML, XML, CSV, JSON, and SARIF formats.
No vendor lock-in: Open-source solution with no licensing costs or vendor dependencies.

Integration capabilities:

Build tool plugins: Maven plugin, Gradle plugin, Ant task for Java build tools.
CI/CD integration: Command-line interface easily integrated into any CI/CD pipeline.
GitHub Actions: Community-maintained GitHub Actions for automated scanning.
Jenkins plugin: Official Jenkins plugin for build-time scanning.

Pricing model:

Free and open-source: Completely free with no licensing costs.
Community support: Support through GitHub issues, mailing lists, and community forums.
Commercial support: Third-party vendors offer commercial support and managed services.

Limitations:

Manual remediation: No automated pull request generation; developers must manually fix vulnerabilities.
Limited license scanning: Focuses primarily on security vulnerabilities rather than comprehensive license compliance.
Basic reachability: No sophisticated reachability analysis to reduce false positives.
Performance: Full scans can be slow, especially for large projects or initial runs.

Best suited for:

Budget-conscious organizations: Teams unable to afford commercial SCA tools.
Open-source projects: Projects preferring open-source tooling without vendor dependencies.
Basic security needs: Organizations needing fundamental vulnerability detection without advanced features.

Black Duck (by Synopsys)

Black Duck is an enterprise-grade commercial SCA platform emphasizing comprehensive security and license risk management.

Key capabilities:

Deep code scanning: Analyzes compiled binaries, source code, and container images to discover dependencies.
Vulnerability intelligence: Proprietary vulnerability database with detailed security research.
License compliance: Comprehensive license risk assessment and policy enforcement across 2,500+ license types.
Component matching: Binary fingerprinting technology identifies components even without manifest files.
Snippet detection: Identifies code snippets copied from open-source projects.
Project intelligence: Provides insights into component maintenance status, community health, and quality metrics.

Integration capabilities:

Detect tool: Flexible command-line tool supporting 30+ languages and package managers.
CI/CD plugins: Plugins for Azure Pipelines, Jenkins, Bamboo, TeamCity, and more.
IDE integration: Plugins for Eclipse, IntelliJ IDEA, and Visual Studio.
Repository scanning: Integrates with Artifactory, Nexus, and other package repositories.
SIEM integration: Integrates with security information and event management (SIEM) systems.

Pricing model:

Enterprise licensing: Subscription-based enterprise licensing with per-project or per-developer pricing.
Professional services: Implementation services and dedicated support available.
No free tier: No free tier; commercial licensing required.

Best suited for:

Enterprise organizations: Large enterprises requiring comprehensive security and compliance management.
Regulated industries: Organizations in finance, healthcare, aerospace with strict compliance requirements.
M&A due diligence: Companies performing acquisition due diligence needing deep code analysis.

JFrog Xray

JFrog Xray is a universal software composition analysis tool integrated with JFrog Artifactory for artifact repository scanning.

Key capabilities:

Universal artifact scanning: Scans any artifact type stored in Artifactory including containers, packages, and build artifacts.
Recursive scanning: Analyzes nested dependencies and embedded components.
Impact analysis: Tracks which applications are affected by vulnerable components.
Policy engine: Flexible policy engine for defining security and compliance rules.
Watch functionality: Monitors specific components or repositories for new vulnerabilities.
DevOps automation: Integrates with CI/CD pipelines to enforce policies at build time.

Integration capabilities:

Artifactory integration: Deep integration with JFrog Artifactory for centralized artifact management.
Build tool plugins: Maven, Gradle, npm, pip, NuGet, and other build tool integrations.
CI/CD integration: Jenkins, Azure Pipelines, GitHub Actions, GitLab CI integrations.
IDE plugins: IntelliJ IDEA, Eclipse, Visual Studio plugins.
REST API: Comprehensive REST API for custom integrations.

Pricing model:

Enterprise product: Included with JFrog Platform Enterprise+ subscription.
Bundled pricing: Pricing includes Artifactory, Xray, and other JFrog platform components.
No standalone option: Requires Artifactory subscription.

Best suited for:

Artifactory users: Organizations already using JFrog Artifactory for artifact management.
Universal artifacts: Teams managing diverse artifact types (containers, packages, binaries).
Centralized governance: Organizations needing centralized artifact scanning and policy enforcement.

Sonatype Nexus Lifecycle

Sonatype Nexus Lifecycle provides software composition analysis integrated with Nexus Repository Manager.

Key capabilities:

Policy management: Flexible policy engine for security, license, and quality requirements.
Automated remediation: Suggests alternative components with fewer vulnerabilities.
Continuous monitoring: Monitors applications continuously for newly disclosed vulnerabilities.
License analysis: Comprehensive license risk assessment and compliance reporting.
Component intelligence: Quality, security, and license risk scoring for components.
Application composition reporting: Detailed reports on application dependencies and risks.

Integration capabilities:

Nexus Repository: Integrated with Nexus Repository Manager for proxy and governance.
IDE plugins: Eclipse, IntelliJ IDEA, Visual Studio plugins.
CI/CD plugins: Jenkins, Bamboo, Azure Pipelines, GitHub Actions integrations.
Build tools: Maven, Gradle, npm, NuGet, and pip integrations.
Issue tracking: Jira, ServiceNow integrations for vulnerability tracking.

Pricing model:

Commercial product: Subscription-based pricing per developer or application.
Nexus bundling: Often purchased as part of Nexus Repository Pro/Enterprise subscriptions.
Enterprise licensing: Custom enterprise agreements with volume discounting.

Best suited for:

Nexus Repository users: Organizations using Sonatype Nexus Repository Manager.
Governance focus: Teams prioritizing component governance and policy enforcement.
Continuous monitoring: Organizations needing ongoing application monitoring post-deployment.

Tool selection criteria

Selecting the right SCA tool requires evaluating multiple factors:

Functional requirements

Vulnerability detection capabilities:

Database coverage: Comprehensive vulnerability database including CVEs, security advisories, and proprietary research.
Update frequency: How quickly new vulnerabilities are added to the database after public disclosure.
False positive rate: Accuracy of vulnerability detection and ability to suppress false positives.
Reachability analysis: Ability to determine whether vulnerable code paths are actually used.

License compliance features:

License detection: Ability to identify licenses from multiple sources (metadata, license files, headers).
License database: Coverage of license types including uncommon and custom licenses.
Policy enforcement: Flexible policy engine for defining license acceptance criteria.
Compliance reporting: Detailed reports for legal teams and auditors.

Remediation guidance:

Fix recommendations: Specific version recommendations that resolve vulnerabilities.
Automated updates: Ability to automatically create pull requests with fixes.
Alternative suggestions: Recommendations for replacing vulnerable or problematic components.
Upgrade path analysis: Guidance on navigating breaking changes when updating dependencies.

Integration capabilities

Development tool integration:

IDE plugins: Real-time feedback in developers' IDEs (VS Code, IntelliJ, Visual Studio).
Git platform support: Integration with GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, Azure Repos.
CI/CD compatibility: Plugins for Azure Pipelines, GitHub Actions, Jenkins, GitLab CI.
Build tool support: Integration with Maven, Gradle, npm, pip, NuGet, etc.

Automation capabilities:

API availability: REST API for custom integrations and automation.
Webhooks: Event notifications for vulnerability alerts and policy violations.
Scheduled scanning: Ability to run scans on schedules independent of builds.
Reporting automation: Automated report generation and distribution.

Technology coverage

Language and ecosystem support:

Programming languages: Support for all languages used in your organization.
Package managers: Coverage of package ecosystems (npm, PyPI, Maven, NuGet, RubyGems, etc.).
Container support: Ability to scan container images and Dockerfiles.
Infrastructure as code: Scanning Terraform, CloudFormation, Kubernetes manifests.

Artifact type support:

Source code: Scanning source repositories and manifest files.
Compiled binaries: Analyzing compiled artifacts (JARs, DLLs, executables).
Container images: Scanning container images in registries.
Deployed applications: Monitoring deployed applications in runtime environments.

Operational considerations

Performance characteristics:

Scan speed: Time required to complete scans for typical projects.
Incremental scanning: Ability to scan only changed dependencies.
Caching: Caching mechanisms to speed up repeated scans.
Scalability: Ability to handle large organizations with thousands of projects.

Usability factors:

Learning curve: Time required for teams to become proficient with the tool.
Dashboard quality: Clarity and usefulness of vulnerability dashboards and reports.
Alert fatigue: Ability to reduce noise through intelligent prioritization.
Documentation: Quality and completeness of user documentation.

Support and maintenance:

Vendor support: Availability and quality of vendor technical support.
Community support: Active user community for open-source tools.
Update frequency: How often the tool receives feature updates and improvements.
Long-term viability: Vendor financial stability and product roadmap.

Cost considerations

Licensing models:

Per-developer pricing: Cost based on number of developers using the tool.
Per-project pricing: Cost based on number of projects or applications scanned.
Consumption pricing: Cost based on actual usage (scans performed, dependencies analyzed).
Enterprise licensing: Flat-rate enterprise agreements for large organizations.

Total cost of ownership:

License costs: Direct software licensing or subscription fees.
Implementation costs: Setup, configuration, and integration efforts.
Training costs: Time and expense of training developers and security teams.
Maintenance costs: Ongoing administration and policy management efforts.
Infrastructure costs: Computing resources required to run scans (especially for on-premises tools).

ROI factors:

Vulnerability reduction: Demonstrated reduction in security incidents.
Compliance savings: Reduced legal risk and audit costs.
Developer productivity: Time saved through automation versus manual processes.
Incident prevention: Cost avoided by preventing security breaches.

GitHub Advanced Security

GitHub Advanced Security provides an integrated, comprehensive security platform built directly into GitHub, offering enterprise-grade capabilities for software supply chain security.

Core capabilities

Dependency security:

Dependabot alerts: Automatic vulnerability detection for dependencies with CVE database integration.
Dependabot security updates: Automated pull requests to remediate vulnerable dependencies.
Dependabot version updates: Scheduled pull requests to keep dependencies current.
Dependency graph: Visual representation of all dependencies and their relationships.
Dependency review: Pull request checks that highlight security implications of dependency changes.

Code security:

Code scanning: Static analysis using CodeQL to detect security vulnerabilities, coding errors, and quality issues in source code.
Secret scanning: Detection of accidentally committed credentials, API keys, tokens, and sensitive data in code and commit history.
Security advisories: Private vulnerability reporting and coordinated disclosure workflow.
SARIF support: Unified format for integrating third-party security tools with GitHub Security.

Container security:

Container scanning: Vulnerability detection in container images stored in GitHub Container Registry.
Dockerfile analysis: Security checks for Dockerfile configurations and base image vulnerabilities.
Registry integration: Automatic scanning of images pushed to GitHub Container Registry.

Platform integration benefits

Native GitHub integration:

Security overview: Organization-wide dashboard showing security posture across all repositories.
Unified alerts: Single location for all security findings (code scanning, secret scanning, Dependabot).
Pull request integration: Security checks run automatically on pull requests with inline annotations.
Branch protection: Require security scans to pass before merging code.
Code owners: Assign security team members to review security-sensitive files.

Developer experience:

Zero configuration: Dependabot requires no setup; enable with a single click.
In-context alerts: Security findings appear directly in the development workflow where developers work.
Auto-fix suggestions: Automated remediation pull requests reduce manual effort.
Low false positives: Curated vulnerability database reduces noise and alert fatigue.
Learning resources: Each alert includes detailed vulnerability descriptions and remediation guidance.

Licensing and availability

Public repositories:

Free tier: All GitHub Advanced Security features are available for free on public repositories.
Community benefit: Open-source projects benefit from enterprise-grade security tooling at no cost.

Private repositories:

GitHub Advanced Security license: Required for private repositories (included with GitHub Enterprise Cloud and GitHub Enterprise Server).
Dependabot access: Dependabot alerts and security updates are available on all GitHub plans for private repositories.
Code scanning and secret scanning: Require Advanced Security license for private repositories.

Enterprise features:

Organization-wide enablement: Configure default security settings for all repositories in the organization.
Policy enforcement: Require security features on all new repositories.
Compliance reporting: Generate audit reports for security compliance frameworks.
Security managers: Designate security team members with read access to all security alerts across the organization.

Use cases and best practices

Ideal for:

GitHub-centric workflows: Organizations using GitHub for version control and collaboration.
Open-source projects: Public repositories benefit from free Advanced Security features.
DevSecOps teams: Teams wanting security integrated directly into development workflows.
Enterprise security: Organizations needing unified security visibility across multiple repositories.
Compliance requirements: Teams requiring audit trails and security policy enforcement.

Implementation approach:

Enable dependency graph: Foundation for all Dependabot features; enable organization-wide.
Activate Dependabot alerts: Start with vulnerability notifications to understand current security posture.
Configure security updates: Enable automated pull requests for high and critical vulnerabilities.
Implement code scanning: Add CodeQL workflow to CI/CD pipeline for static analysis.
Enable secret scanning: Prevent credential leaks with automatic detection.
Review and triage alerts: Establish processes for reviewing, prioritizing, and remediating security findings.
Enforce with branch protection: Require security checks to pass before allowing code merges.

Tool comparison matrix

Feature	GitHub Advanced Security	Mend	Snyk	OWASP Dependency-Check	Black Duck	GitHub Dependabot	JFrog Xray	Nexus Lifecycle
Vulnerability Detection	Excellent	Excellent	Excellent	Good	Excellent	Good	Excellent	Excellent
License Compliance	Basic	Excellent	Good	Basic	Excellent	Basic	Good	Excellent
Automated Remediation	Yes (Dependabot)	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Limited	Limited
Reachability Analysis	Limited	Yes	Yes	No	Limited	No	Limited	Limited
Container Scanning	Yes	Yes	Yes	Limited	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
Code Scanning (SAST)	Yes (CodeQL)	Limited	Limited	No	Limited	No	Limited	Limited
Secret Scanning	Yes	Limited	Limited	No	No	No	Limited	Limited
IDE Integration	Yes (GitHub Codespaces)	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No (Native GitHub)	Yes	Yes
CI/CD Integration	Excellent (GitHub Actions)	Excellent	Excellent	Good	Excellent	Excellent (GitHub)	Excellent	Excellent
Multi-Language Support	20+	200+	30+	20+	30+	15+	30+	25+
Pricing	Free (Public) / Enterprise	Commercial	Freemium	Free	Commercial	Free (GitHub)	Commercial	Commercial
Best For	GitHub organizations	Enterprise	Developers	Budget-conscious	Regulated industries	GitHub users	Artifactory users	Nexus users

Evaluation approach

Trial and proof of concept:

Identify requirements: Document your specific security, compliance, and integration requirements.
Shortlist tools: Select 2-3 tools matching your requirements for detailed evaluation.
Run pilot projects: Test tools with representative projects covering your technology stack.
Measure effectiveness: Evaluate vulnerability detection accuracy, false positive rates, and remediation guidance quality.
Assess integration: Test integrations with your existing development tools and workflows.
Gather feedback: Collect feedback from developers, security teams, and operations staff.
Calculate ROI: Estimate total cost of ownership and expected return on investment.
Make decision: Select tool providing best combination of functionality, usability, integration, and cost.

Selecting the right Software Composition Analysis tool requires carefully balancing functional capabilities, integration requirements, technology coverage, operational considerations, and cost. The best tool depends on your organization's specific needs, existing toolchain, technology stack, and budget. Organizations using GitHub benefit from GitHub Advanced Security's tight integration with development workflows, while those requiring extensive license compliance capabilities may prefer commercial solutions like Mend or Black Duck. Many organizations achieve success by starting with free or low-cost tools like GitHub Dependabot or OWASP Dependency-Check and upgrading to commercial solutions as their maturity and requirements grow. GitHub Advanced Security provides an excellent middle ground, offering enterprise-grade security features with seamless GitHub integration. The next unit explores how to automate container image scanning as part of comprehensive SCA practices.

Feedback

Was this page helpful?